Home

What Is Deep Dish Pizza and How Do You Make It?

Deep dish pizza is a pizza you bake in a deep, oiled pan, with dough pressed across the base and up the sides to hold a generous filling. To make it, you layer cheese and any other fillings inside the dough, spread tomato sauce on top, then bake until the crust is browned and the centre is hot.

What makes deep dish pizza different?

What sets it apart is how you assemble it, not simply the thickness of the base. You shape the dough into a shallow shell around the filling, while the pan supports the tall sides and helps brown the crust. Aim for a crisp underside, a tender interior and enough structure to support a generous layer of cheese and tomatoes.

With ordinary thick-crust pan pizza, you generally spread toppings over a breadier base. Deep dish gets more of its height from the filling and raised edges, although the thickness of the dough varies between recipes.

Stuffed pizza is different again: you cover the filling with a second, thin sheet of dough, usually with sauce above it. You don't add an upper dough layer to a standard deep dish pizza.

What do you need to make deep dish pizza?

For one pizza in a metal pan about 23 cm wide and at least 4 cm deep, use the quantities below as a starting point. You'll get approximately four substantial portions, depending on how much filling you add.

  • Dough: 300 g plain or all-purpose flour, 170 ml lukewarm water, 3 g instant yeast, 5 g fine salt and 35 ml olive oil or another cooking oil.
  • Cheese: 250 g low-moisture mozzarella, sliced or coarsely grated, plus 20 g grated hard cheese if you like.
  • Sauce: 350 g thick crushed tomatoes, weighed after draining any excess liquid, with dried oregano and salt to taste.
  • Optional fillings: 100 to 150 g cooked, drained meat or cooked vegetables with excess moisture removed.
  • Oil for the pan: approximately 1 tablespoon to coat the base and sides.

A metal pan gives you more reliable browning than a ceramic dish. You can use a deep pizza pan, a metal cake tin without a loose base or an oven-safe cast-iron frying pan. Check that any handle can withstand your baking temperature.

Use low-moisture mozzarella rather than fresh mozzarella packed in liquid. Watery cheese, undrained tomatoes and raw mushrooms can release enough moisture to leave your base soft. Some recipes call for cornmeal, but you don't need it to make deep dish pizza.

How to make deep dish pizza dough

Mix the flour, instant yeast and salt, then add the water and oil. Stir until no dry flour remains, and knead for about 5 to 8 minutes, until the dough feels smooth and pliable. It should feel soft but hold its shape without sticking heavily to your hands.

Cover the bowl and let the dough rise until roughly doubled, typically 1 to 2 hours depending on room temperature and yeast activity. Judge the rise by how much the dough expands rather than relying only on the clock.

Oil the pan thoroughly, then gently flatten the dough into a disc. Press it across the base and about 3 to 4 cm up the sides, keeping the bottom reasonably even. Avoid leaving a thick ridge where the base meets the sides.

If the dough repeatedly shrinks back, rest it for 10 minutes before continuing. This gives the stretched dough time to relax, so you can shape it without tearing it. Patch any holes before adding the filling.

How to layer deep dish pizza

The usual order is cheese first, sauce last. By placing the cheese beneath the tomatoes, you protect it from direct oven heat during the longer bake. The thick sauce cooks on top without exposing the cheese to burning.

  1. Cover the dough base with mozzarella, spreading it evenly to the edges.
  2. Add any cooked meat or vegetables in a modest, even layer.
  3. Spoon the thick tomatoes over the filling, keeping them inside the raised dough edge.
  4. Finish with oregano and a little grated hard cheese, if using.

Don't pack the filling down or pile it above the dough rim. If you overfill the pizza, you'll make the centre harder to heat through and increase the chance of liquid spilling over. Cook raw meat before adding it, and drain away excess fat.

How long should you bake deep dish pizza?

Preheat a conventional oven to 220°C, or a fan oven to approximately 200°C. Place a rack in the lower third so the base receives enough heat before the exposed edge becomes too dark.

Bake the assembled pizza for approximately 30 to 40 minutes, checking from about 25 minutes. Your pan material, filling depth and oven accuracy all affect timing, so use this range as a guide rather than a fixed rule.

Look for a deep golden-brown rim, bubbling sauce near the centre and a firm, browned underside. Carefully lift an edge with a thin spatula to inspect the base. If the rim browns too quickly, loosely shield it with foil and continue baking.

If the bottom is pale and flexible, give the pizza more time or move it to a lower rack. Before your next bake, also make sure you drain the tomatoes well and fully preheat the oven.

How to serve deep dish pizza

Let the pizza rest in its pan for about 10 to 15 minutes before cutting. The filling will settle slightly, making each slice easier to lift. Loosen the edges with a suitable spatula, cut into wedges and use a broad server to support the base.

Refrigerate within two hours, or within one hour if the surrounding temperature exceeds 32°C. Store portions in shallow, covered containers and use refrigerated leftovers within 3 to 4 days, following guidance from the USDA Food Safety and Inspection Service.

Reheat slices on a metal tray in an oven at about 180°C until the centre reaches 74°C. Cover loosely if the rim starts to darken. You can heat a portion quickly in a microwave, but you'll get a softer crust than if you reheat it in the oven.

Sources